The Educated Kiwi
New MacBooks, but what is Apple thinking?
I had waited expectantly for today’s announcement of new MacBook and MacBook Pro computers. They look sleek, shiny and elegant like one would expect from apple. Alas there is a hidden catch, the MacBook Pro has dropped firewire 400 in favour of firewire 800, that in itself is no particularly big deal, some different cables will pretty much take care of it for most people or there is an adapter for the express port. The MacBook now has no firewire port at all and I cannot help but wonder what that will mean for schools and for the future of the MacBook in the TELA programme.
You may recall that the first TELA MacBooks were the top of the range black models, that was because they had a hard drive big enough to meet the minimum specifications for the TELA programme which the lower cost models did not. Is Firewire a requirement for a laptop to be offered under the TELA programme? If anyone knows a definitive answer on that then I would love to know.
But what about the schools (and others) that have an investment in firewire equipment? Lots of schools have firewire video cameras and hard drives. This seems like a bad step, and one that will likely annoy more than a few people.
Then one has to wonder, if they dropped firewire on the MacBook, does that mean that they will also drop it on the Mac Mini? What about the iMac range when it gets the next update?
I guess we will all get over it in the course of time, but buying gear that still works just fine but cannot be plugged into your computer always sucks.
| Print article | This entry was posted by whall on October 15, 2008 at 7:41 pm, and is filed under Hardware, School. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
about 1 year ago
… and also loosing FW port means that you can’t boot from an external drive!! This is a critical loss!! I use superduper to back up my HDD and then if my HD fails – as has happened twice! – I can then run from an external drive and keep functioning using another intel mac laptop until my computer is fixed. Really handy feature.
Apple has seemed committed to FW in the past so this is a radical departure.
NOT good!!!
cheers
Greg
about 1 year ago
I have long teased apple owners about being on the dark side of the force, but one thing I have liked is the ease of connectivity and simplicity of media editing. Its so much easier on a mac or should I say it was.
I suspect that the marketing guru who suggested that was actually employed by a competitor.
Well at least the apple logo is now explained – some one just took a great big bite out of it!
A
about 1 year ago
I couldn’t agree more Greg, the loss of the target disk mode functionality of FW will be a real blow to anyone doing tech support on macs. Yes they let you use Migration Manager with USB or ethernet but part of the power of target disk mode is that your drive can be really corrupted and your machine will still allow you to boot to target disk so that you can have a crack at fixing it or recovering data. To use USB or ethernet your machine has to be bootable still.
about 1 year ago
I do see that the base ‘white’ model still has firewire could this be an interim measure for education like the emacs we had before?
about 1 year ago
You can get a FW400 FW800 cable usually. I’m pretty sure I did have one floating around which overcomes this little but annoying problem.